Sunday, May 29, 2011

Shocking Dog Training Results

We finally broke down and bought the shock collar for the Tucker Monster. I was against it, considered it animal abuse, and would never even consider it when Matt suggested it.

We've had an off balanced house since we brought Tucker home in February 2010. He was about 6 months old when he came home to live with Matt, Molly and Me. Molly put up with his antics, his nipping, his toy stealing and his pushy behavior because he was a puppy. We put up with it because we were letting him adjust, and working on other behavior problems, like house breaking and basic commands. We figured Molly and Tucker would shake out their pecking order in due time.

Fast forward 7-8 when we started with our trainer. She helped us see when we needed to intervene in Molly and Tucker's tiffs, and when we need to let them duke it out. Then we had a long, lazy, blue winter where we blamed all of our behavior problems and rough interactions on lack of exercise (ie. lazy dog parents!).

When spring broke, Matt really took charge of walking both dogs at the same time. He found that Tucker was much more manageable when being walked in between Molly and Matt. We also switched his collar again. We started the prong collar on both dogs with the trainer, and that worked awesome on Molly, but not great with Tuck. He would get frustarated and refuse to walk when he was getting corrected. We switched him over to a regular choke chain and he improved. We happen to have a gentle leader that we tried to use with Molly. As an aside, the gentle leader did not properly fit Molly who is a pit bull mix. We were never able to get it to sit correctly on her muzzle, and we tried two different sizes. The larger of the two gentle leaders fit Tuck perfectly. So, the gentle leader combined with walking between Molly and Matt made Tuck a confident, balanced walker.

However, that was the only place we were finding balance with Tucker. We live in a twin house, and our attached neighbors got a new puppy in February. Molly accepted the new puppy pretty well. Tuck did not. He freaked out whenever he saw the puppy, barking constantly until he was hoarse, running up and down the fence, just completely losing it. And, this wasn't just once, this was every single day, 3-4 times a day. The poor 8 week old puppy was terrified, and having trouble house breaking because of his fear of my dog.

We consulted our trainer, and she suggested a meet and greet out front on neutral territory. This worked wonderfully for Molly. She bowed and played and let the puppy sniff her. Tucker spent 30 minutes acting like a bucking bronco just absolutely terrifying the poor puppy. We eventually gave up.

While we were in the backyard, we tried redirecting with rewards, including dog treats, people food, and toys. We tried leashing him and letting him just bark it out, hoping he would tire out and realize there is no reason to be so excited. Nothing worked.

Earlier this week, after a pretty bad time outside, Tucker came inside, picked a fight with Molly and when Matt intervened, he bit a hole in Molly's ear. It was a small puncture wound, but it was enough to bring our lack of balance screaming to the front of our minds. I agreed to the shock collar. The one with the remote control. We bought it at Petco for approximately $160. (If you are considering the same collar we bought, we saw it today at Lowes for approximately $120, way cheaper!).

Our first use, we realized that settings 1, 2, and 3 did not even register for Tucker. Once we had it set to 4, he noticed. He got upset and moved away from the fence onto the deck (we consider the deck "base", no dog fighting, no toy stealing if we can help it). At first he thought it had something to do with the fence. When he approached the fence again gingerly, and realized it wasn't the fence, he started getting excited again and barking. Shocked again, and he was stopped in his tracks. We could see the little wheels turning in his head as he realized the fence wasn't the source but his excitement/barking was the source. We still allowed running up and down the fence and standing up on the fence looking into the neighbors yard (for the time being), as long as it was quiet. It really only took 4 shocks before he had put it together. It was amazing.

Now, we've set up our word identifier, and using the tone button as a warning prior to the shock. We really have only had to use the shock 1-2 times a day for the past few days as a reminder, but saying QUIET and using the tone works wonders as a redirect. I really have to say, it's been an amazing transformation.

We've used the collar now 3 times to deal with Tuck's excitement when we have guests. The tone button works great to get his attention, and we continue to use the word QUIET even though he's not actually barking (a huge improvement over how he used to great our guests!). And since he's so calm, he's able to focus on things besides jumping all over our friends and family. He will play fetch with my 7 year old nephew without jumping on him. He got a little too excited, but we were able to use the tone button to calm him back down. It is awesome!

I feel like we have been trying to communicate with Tucker from day one, and because our methods were not as direct and real time enough for him to understand. And I feel like he FINALLY gets it. Molly has been more dominating in their play since we've started using the shock collar, and Tucker has been really receptive to it. It feels like we've been fighting the pecking order for the past year and finally Matt and I are in charge, and Molly is taking her place as alpha dog.

More updates to come as we continue to have success!

1 comment:

  1. And now Tucker is calm enough to play rummy with the family!!

    ReplyDelete